Becoming A Creative Expert

"I see only one move ahead"

Several discussions took place this week between myself and a few friends. Not all were professional photographers. Nor were they artists or designers. All called themselves photographers because they owned digital SLRs and had sold some of their photos which they thought placed them among those of us who make our livings from photography. Scientific America, in a 2006 article, used a California State University, Fullerton professor’s anthropological study of chess to help explain how experts are created.

Chess has its own criteria for determining a player’s placement in the hierarchy of experts. A major factor in the rating system is assessing expertise on performance rather than reputation. The results are remarkably accurate according to the magazine with winners easily predetermined by comparing their rating scores. However, one player’s progress to a higher rating came from stronger structural knowledge of the game and less analysis of each possible move.

Owning a digital SLR instead of a film camera automatically removes barriers that prevented most people from acquiring more knowledge about photographic craft. Instant results viewable on a small LCD screen instead of waiting for processed slide film can accelerate the learning curve making it easier to gain the structural knowledge necessary for creative success. Failure becomes immediately measurable and correctable without additional monetary cost. On-screen analysis of technique and results quickly advances the body of skills necessary to advance to a better understanding of the craft. It doesn’t guarantee success, just more knowledge.

Moore’s Law that computer power doubling every 18 months has proven quite accurate. Especially when each successive high-end computer-driven digital camera has faster processors, more memory, better ergonomics, and greater resolution. Just as stronger, faster, and cheaper computers has rapidly changed how society communicates, works, and learns, digital camera advancements will continue to make it easier for people to become photographers.

Precocity among this new group of "creatives" undercuts the value of photographic masters who’ve accumulated much greater structural knowledge of the skills and techniques required for creative and business success. Owning and using the greatest in technology doesn’t make one an expert or allow them to excel at the craft. My #2 pencil, among the lowest example of technological achievements, is nothing more than wood and charcoal in my hands. In the hands of David Meyer, an artist friend, it is a tool for artistic success.

Herbert A. Simon’s psychological law that it takes ten years of study to become expert in a field strengthens the argument. Studies of Mozart’s designation as a child prodigy indicate that his earliest works were heavily corrected by his father, himself a composer, and that even his earliest serious works were derivative, not original.

Determining success may be measured by a variety of factors from financial to artistic. For professional photographers, that measure has become financial as advanced amateurs and semi-pros gather extended knowledge and experience.

The challenge for pro photographers becomes how to separate themselves from this new group of talented, expressive, creative people who are quickly accumulating the skills to challenge our business.

"Without a demonstrably immense superiority in skill over the novice, there can be no true experts, only laypeople with imposing credentials. Such, alas, are all too common." – Scientific America

Read More at Scientific America

Photo News

10 Ways to Fight for Your Digital Rights as a Photographer

June 1st New Yorker Cover Drawn Entirely on the iPhone

Twitter News & Tweets

Ton of Twitter Video Sources

The Social Media Use of Obama and McCain

Dell Says It Has Earned $3 Million From Twitter – Bits Blog – NYTimes.com

Army Orders End to Ban on Facebook, Twitter

8 Reasons Why Personal Historians Should Use Twitter

Facebook News

The Social Revolution: Myspace Vs. Facebook

Coming Soon: Facebook Usernames

A New Hope for Smartphones

More Creativity Readings

Photographing The Mundane

Creativity: Flow and the Psychology of Discovery and Invention

An Emotional Memorial Week

Two Minute Trip through The Emotions Of Life TV

The script for bee.tv’s Anthem takes you across streets and sidewalks, phone booths, bedrooms, playgrounds, garages and roof tops, casting a watchful gaze over some of life’s most powerful and poignant moments. From lawbreaking to love making, the spot highlights the depth of experience available through Bee.tv’s personalised content platforms, deftly delivered with a usual light touch and painterly eye for detail. [ Hot Shots ]

Pepsi Wants You Advertising

Pepsi has a special deal for out of work journalists with an “open newsroom” experiment to widen its brand through increase social media participation. Offering a $750 stipend, the program is open to journalists, students, social media gadflies and anyone with a hankering to report using social media tools. PepsiCo has made a concerted push to align itself with social media. It was among the top sponsors at South by Southwest, a social media Woodstock held in April. Its efforts there included a Twitter visualizer that tracked sentiment from the event and a podcast area. It also hosted a “PepTrends” event, in which it moderated a conversation over Twitter about global trends. [ AdWeek ]

In Defense of Copyright Creativity

“The genius of the framers in making this provision is that it allows for infinite adjustment. Congress is free to extend at will the term of copyright. It last did so in 1998, and should do so again, as far as it can throw. Would it not be just and fair for those who try to extract a living from the uncertain arts of writing and composing to be freed from a form of confiscation not visited upon anyone else? The answer is obvious, and transcends even justice. No good case exists for the inequality of real and intellectual property, because no good case can exist for treating with special disfavor the work of the spirit and the mind. [ Lessig ]

Google to Newspapers: “Block us” Media

Well fine, if publishers don’t want their content crawled, they can easily tag their content with a “Robot” which blocks Google’s spiders from crawling and indexing their pages, says Google spokesman Gabriel Stricker in this interview. [ Beet.tv ]

Ten Ways to Stand Out At An Event Networking

1. Be sexier. Read the rest at your peril. [ Chris Brogan ]

This Week In Newspapers

Washington governor approves newspaper tax cuts [ Seattle Times ]

A Case for a “King of News”? [ Rosenblum.tv ]

Should Washington Bail Out Newspapers? [ Reason.tv ]

A Documentary on the Death of Newspapers [ Rosenblum.tv ]

Photo News

New York Times starts Photo Blog

Mental illness in America’s prisons

Tim Hetherington interview

Low Res fine art

352x

American Photography Winners

Shepard Fairey ripoff, again?

More Shepard Fairey

Twitter News & Tweets

Venti to go for Starbucks

Twitter to do business apps

Best ways to use Twitter

Twitter Advertising?

NASA Tweets not so fast

Twitter continues usage climb

Facebook News

OpenID Logins

American Idol Passion

No IPO

Google replaced by social media?

The Pope’s Facebook app

Viral Videos

At the polling station

Kobe and Lebron

HD camera trick

HD camera trick revealed

Oxygen

Where’s the Inspiration?

The Insanity of Inspiration.

“I’ve been thinking a lot about the most important skill a photographer can possess in order to have a successful career. After crunching the numbers and analyzing the empirical data the evidence is clear; success doesn’t rely on skill as much as it relies on inspiration; the paranormal event that fuels the creation of brilliant images that is totally unreliable in its visitations to your career.” [ APA National ]

A Different Way To Think About Creative Genius

All creatives dream. Photographers, writers, designers, musicians, dancers, chefs… dream of doing something so phenomenal that the whole world suddenly knows about it. We dream. We practice. We work. We think. When we’re lucky, we truly create. What is the nature of creativity? Where does it comes from? Where does it go? [ Pixsylated ] Eds Note: My apologies to Pixsylated who I failed to properly credit for this posting.

Invasion of the Shutterbugs

At a time when people in all kinds of careers are looking for a Plan B, there’s one that’s already teeming with dabblers: photography. Amateurs with digital cameras are hanging out shingles, offering to shoot portraits of people, pets and, even more challenging, weddings — skimming business from professionals while, some say, knocking off their style at lower quality. [ Crains - Chicago ]

Playboy Plans ‘Radical Changes’ to Print Model

During its quarterly earnings call Monday, Jerome Kern, Playboy Enterprises’ interim chairman and CEO, said the company is considering “radical changes” to its print business model. The publisher reported a $13.7 million net loss during the first quarter of 2009, compared to a $4.2 million loss during the same period in 2008. Revenues for the period were $61.8 million, down more than 20 percent from $78.5 million during the same period last year. [ Folio Magazine ]

Obama Girls Used With Murdered Kids Story

On Wednesday, a story featured on the Washington Times website about murdered Chicago schoolchildren was inexplicably paired with a photo of President Obama’s daughters. The two girls are not mentioned in the story, and aside from having at one point been schoolchildren in Chicago have no connection to it. [ Huffington Post ]

Copyright Critics Rationalize Theft

Imagine a city of many millions of people who support themselves and their families solely by arranging words, images and sounds, or in the industries that make this work available to others. They neither farm, fish, mine, manufacture, manage, heal, teach, build nor defend. But what they do influences most everything, shapes politics and governance, provides a conception of our time, forges the culture such as it is, and stamps the imprint of the present for history to judge. Though builders may build, in the main they follow the plans of architects. Teachers teach, but they must have a text. Politicians govern, but only upon the flow of commentary that raises them up or casts them down. [ WSJ ]

This Week In Newspapers

American Press On Suicide Watch [ New York Times ]

Bad Day For Newsrooms And Democracy [ TruthOut ]

David Simon On The Downfall Of American Newspapers [ MediaBistro ]

Photo News

A conversastion with Amy Stein

CBSNews.com – Redesigned with More Photos

Arnold in 1985

Bill Jay – RIP

Linsey Addario Injured in Pakistan

Lessons 46-50

Flight 1549 Photos Published With Airlines Logos Removed

What will become of photojournalism in an age of bytes and amateurs?

Twitter News & Tweets

Twitter’s On Fire!

Photographers on Twitter

Canada Gets Twitterized

NASA Tweets

Facebook News

ADL urges Facebook block Holocaust-deniers

Facebook Virtual Payments

Facebook Face.com photo scans

First Verified Facebook App

Facebook Easter Egg

Viral Videos

Apple Elimination

MOMA: I see

Stride: Heirloom

NBA: Shaq

Transform :: A short film for Scott Kelby